Plagiarism Policy
NBME maintains strict standards for originality and proper attribution through comprehensive plagiarism detection and prevention measures aligned with international best practices.
Plagiarism Definition: Plagiarism encompasses any form of unauthorized appropriation including verbatim copying without attribution, paraphrasing without citation, self-plagiarism through duplicate publication, idea appropriation without acknowledgment, and unauthorized collaboration or ghostwriting.
Detection Systems: Comprehensive plagiarism screening includes:
- Automated similarity detection using professional software (iThenticate/Turnitin)
- Cross-referencing against international publication databases
- Manual expert review for subtle forms of appropriation
- Reference verification and citation analysis
- Author self-declaration requirements regarding originality
Screening Thresholds: Similarity analysis employs nuanced interpretation considering:
- Overall similarity percentages above 15% trigger detailed editorial review
- Individual matches exceeding 5% require specific justification
- Field-specific conventions for methodology descriptions and standard terminology
- Appropriate citation and quotation practices in context
- Previous work by the same authors with proper self-citation
Investigation Procedures: Suspected plagiarism triggers systematic investigation including:
- Comprehensive evidence documentation and source identification
- Author notification with opportunity for explanation and clarification
- Expert panel review for complex cases requiring disciplinary expertise
- Institutional notification for confirmed violations
- Collaboration with other publishers for systematic violators
Sanctions and Remedies: Plagiarism violations result in graduated responses including:
- Manuscript rejection with detailed explanation for moderate violations
- Publication retraction with permanent notice for published articles
- Author submission restrictions for specified periods based on violation severity
- Institutional notification for severe or repeated violations
- Collaboration with integrity organizations for systematic misconduct
Educational Support: NBME provides proactive education including detailed guidelines on proper citation practices, workshops on academic integrity standards, resources for international authors unfamiliar with Western citation conventions, and mentorship support for early-career researchers developing scholarly writing skills.